CIRI Research

Join the Discussion on LinkedIn!

Support CIRI!


We Support CIRI - Cleaning Industry Research Institute


Show your support of CIRI with the 'CIRI Supporter' logo, available for display on your Web site upon joining CIRI.


Join today and help CIRI advance the cause of cleaner, more productive, and healthier indoor environments through scientific research!

Popular Topics

Did You Know?


Traditional Cleaning Methods Ineffective


In a study at a Cleveland, OH Veterans Administration hospital, cleaning methods the housekeeping staff were using prior to an educational intervention were only successful in eliminating surface contamination by serious human pathogens about 23-25% of the time.


Dr. Paul Darby, MD, PhD, MPH, CIME, FACOEM


Promises and Pitfalls of Surface Disinfection


By Syed A. Sattar, PhD




Hard, nonporous environmental surfaces in health care settings are now receiving due recognition for their role in the spread of several types of nosocomial pathogens. The corresponding increase in the means to decontaminate such surfaces to interrupt the spread of infections is leading to the marketing of a plethora of products and procedures, including the ‘‘green’’ variety, with varying claims of microbicidal activity, human and environmental safety, and materials compatibility.


Limitations of the existing methods to assess environmental surface disinfectants and the regulations that govern their premarket registration make objective evaluations difficult.


Label claims of many such products also do not reflect the realities of field use along with a strong tendency to focus on the ‘‘bug de jour.’’ Furthermore, whereas wiping is often an integral part of environmental surface decontamination, products meant for the purpose are rarely assessed with the physical effect of wiping incorporated.


Many ‘‘green’’ products possess neither the spectrum of microbicidal activity nor the speed of action essential for use in health care settings. In general, ‘‘self-sanitizing’’ surfaces being marketed actively these days require greater scrutiny for field-relevant microbicidal activity as well as the potential to enhance microbicide resistance.


The widening use of environmental surface disinfectants is also raising concerns on their human and environmental safety at many levels along with the realization that routine surface disinfection procedures in health care settings are frequently inadequate and possibly counterproductive.


All this points to an urgent review of the basic procedures for assessing existing and new environmental surface disinfectants for their microbicidal activity, label claims, registration requirements, overall safety, and routine practices of environmental surface decontamination.

"Promises and pitfalls of recent advances in chemical means of preventing the spread of nosocomial infections by environmental surfaces"

Author: Syed A. Sattar, PhD, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Copyright 2010 by the Association for Professionals in Infection Control and Epidemiology, Inc. Published by Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. (Am J Infect Control 2010; 38:S34-40.)



Promises and Pitfalls of Surface Disinfection :  Created on January 18th, 2011.  Last Modified on January 18th, 2011
Disclaimer ↓

The Cleaning Industry Research Institute (CIRI) is a 501.c.3 not-for-profit scientific, educational and research organization that applies science to the practice and improvement of cleaning and maintenance.


This abstract/brief is presented under the recognized "fair use" doctrine with respect to article copyright and intellectual property. Readers are encouraged to secure the full article from the originating publication source. Articles also may be obtained through a librarian, an information specialist or inter-library loan. In cases where payment is required under copyright it can be processed through a reference library or the Copyright Clearance Center at


CIRI provides no warranty, expressed or implied, and assumes no legal liability for the accuracy, completeness or usefulness of any information disclosed on its site. The views and opinions of authors expressed herein do not necessarily reflect those of CIRI principals, executives, science advisors or affiliates.





Member Access

Sorry, only CIRI Members are allowed to comment.


If you're a member, sign in:

Not a CIRI Member? Join Today to tap CIRI knowledge and networking resources



Comment by Bob Robinson Sr on January 18th, 2011 at 9:02am

As an industry, we put too much faith in chemicals to make our surfaces safe. When using a disinfectant (usually with a dirty rag), we forget about the instructions that say "remove gross soils" before using, which results in very ineffective germ killing and poor cleaning. We are left with a false sense of security. It is frightening how much soil and germs are left behind after we have "disinfected" with our EPA registered disinfectants. I hope as an industry we will begin to objectively measure and evaluate how poorly we are doing in the area of disinfection and sanitizing. It's time to open our eyes, ears, and mouths to this big problem.






Popular Topics: Swine Flu | H1N1 | MRSA | Staph | Norovirus | Flu | E. Coli | C. Difficile | Salmonella | Green Cleaning | Cleaning for Health | Nosocomial Infections | Disinfection | Bacteria | Viruses | Indoor Air Quality | Asthma | Allergies | Allergen | Mold


© 2007-2014 The Cleaning Industry Research Institute
A 501.c.3 not-for-profit scientific, educational and research institute
1988 Central Avenue
Albany, NY 12205

Phone: (888)285-2474 or (518)690-0479
Fax: (518)456-6445
Privacy Policy | Shipping Policy | Return Policy & Procedure

This site donated by:

Kaivac Cleaning Systems®